Does the amending of bail conditions and subsequent release from house arrest of former International Monetary Fund managing director Dominique Strauss-Kahn, accused of sexually assaulting a maid at his New York City hotel on May 14, mean he’s not guilty? The District Attorney has not dismissed any of the charges against Strauss-Kahn, but you’d think he had and that Strauss-Kahn had been unanimously acquitted from on high from much of the media coverage. Now that some inconsistencies have allegedly been found in the story of the Guinean immigrant woman who accused Strauss-Kahn of rape, that apparently settles it: it’s impossible that she’s been a victim. Let the trashing begin!
Why? Because she lied on her application for asylum in the United States, hardly a rarity for people desperate for the chance at a better life. She also lied on her income tax returns by including a child that wasn’t hers. Illegal, yes, but let’s not pretend that lying on your income tax returns isn’t common practice. The woman also discussed the case via telephone in a taped conversation with an incarcerated marijuana dealer, during which she allegedly said that she both knew what she was doing in pressing charges and that Strauss-Kahn was wealthy. Again, so what? Let’s be real: with the phony war on drugs and disparity in sentencing, many of us know people incarcerated for drugs, and not just weed, either. And let’s not play coy and perpetuate the pretense that the American Dream isn’t for sale, highly expensive, and that aggrieved people don’t want monetary compensation along with that helping of justice.
It’s time to permanently bury the delusion that false rape claims are common, when such claims occur less than 3% of the time. Ditto the prejudice that it’s only rape when a victim’s conduct is beyond reproach. This mythical, perfect victim doesn’t exist. Neither should an absurd standard that having had too much to drink, or multiple past sexual partners, or lying on an application for asylum, or knowing someone in prison on drug charges – honestly, who doesn’t or hasn’t?! – negates our right to assert that we were raped and to have those charges pursued in a court of law. As it is, if you’re not the perfect victim, you’re turned into a perpetrator. The New York Post has been making the totally unsubstantiated charge that Strauss-Kahn’s accuser is a prostitute. I shudder to think of what could be unearthed and distorted in my past with unlimited resources. I’m not sure about those trees falling in the forest, but if the victim is imperfect, does that mean no crime can be committed?
I don’t know what transpired on May 14 in that room at the Sofitel. I also don’t know what happened to 36-year-old Marie Joseph, whose body was found in the bottom of a public pool in Fall River, Massachusetts after it had laid there two days. None of Joseph’s friends with whom she’d gone to the pool reported her missing. According to news reports, her boyfriend said he figured she “Wanted to be alone,” which explained her disappearance at the pool and not answering her phone for 48 hours. What does it say about how little value Joseph had that when she vanished no one, not even her man, looked for her?
I don’t know if Dominque Strauss-Kahn is guilty or innocent. What I do know is that too often women, and black women in particular, are treated as if we are disposable, to be used by others as needed, discarded when it is convenient, and if we live to speak out or file charges destroyed by a media doing the bidding of the wealthy, powerful and male when we respond inconveniently. Where is our right to a fair hearing, to justice? (According to news reports, Tristane Banon, a 32-year-old French woman journalist will file charges Tuesday that Strauss-Kahn raped her in 2003. It will be fascinating to observe how her allegations will be received.)
What I do know is that Dominque Strauss-Kahn has resources at his command that most of us cannot imagine. I know that he has spent a lifetime supported by the benefits of white supremacy and male privilege. His accuser, a black woman from the tiny nation of Guinea, has more than likely lived a life characterized by vulnerability, exploitation and defenselessness. Unless the alleged victim recants, let the trial proceed. Let justice be done in a court of law, not behind the closed doors of the District Attorney’s office or the courts of the press or public opinion.
A Note: And in the “Give me a cup of smug with that pseudo-news” while we’re at it category, here’s a clip of MSNBC analyst and Time magazine columnist Mark Halperin’s revealing characterization of President Obama after his June 29 press conference, during which he took Republicans to the proverbial woodshed around their insane debt ceiling manuevers.
Finally: I’ll be attending and speaking at SisterSong; Women of Color Reproductive Justice Collective conference in Miami, Let’s Talk About Sex: Love, Legislation and Leadership, July 14 – 17. This is an absolutely wonderful, activist coalition of national organizations committed to defending women’s rights. They’re also dedicated to having a fabulous time while fighting the good fight. The conference promises to be enlightening, inspiring, and fun! Hope to see you there.









